A collective of 215 concerned citizens, scholars, and intellectuals, including Vice Chancellors of leading universities as well as directors of the Indian Institutes of Management and Technology (IIMs and IITs), issued an open letter to Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on Thursday, condemning her political mockery directed at IIT Madras director V. Kamakoti.
The letter criticised her jibe in the Lok Sabha on July 28, reportedly referring to Prof. Kamakoti as a “gaumutra expert”, during a discussion on The Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Amendment Bill, 2026.
Signatories to the letter argued that such characterisations bypass substantive debate in favour of dismissive political caricatures, threatening the foundational principles of scientific temper enshrined in the Indian Constitution.
‘Top tech brain’
The open letter highlighted Prof. Kamakoti’s credentials, stating that he holds M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in Computer Science and Engineering from IIT Madras and has authored over 150 research papers and headed more than 50 Research and Development (R&D) projects.
“He has several honours and accolades to his name, including the DRDO Academic Excellence Award and the Indian Electronics and Semiconductor Association Techno Visionary Award. He has been the guiding force behind India’s first industry grade microprocessor. Needless to say, he is one of the top tech brains of the country,” the letter noted.
The signatories argued that top-tier scholarship warrants institutional respect, regardless of ideological friction on specific topics.
‘Undermines scientific temper’
They asserted that academics must retain the autonomy to present hypotheses, explore traditional knowledge systems, and participate in national conversations, without fear of institutional reprisal or public degradation.
“To dismiss a scholar through a label rather than engage with the substance of his views risks undermining the very scientific temper that our Constitution calls upon every citizen to develop,” the letter said.
“Scientific temper is not merely scepticism towards unconventional ideas, it is equally the willingness to examine claims objectively before accepting or rejecting them. History reminds us that many ideas once considered implausible eventually found scientific validation, while many widely accepted beliefs were later discarded,” it added.
‘Chilling effect’
The letter’s authors noted that political rhetoric can impact the broader scientific ecosystem in India. They warned that reducing educators and researchers to partisan soundbites creates a chilling effect, discouraging experts from engaging in vital public debates.
“Equally troubling is the message such remarks send to India’s academic and research community. Our scientists, scholars and educators deserve to know that they can participate in public debate without fear of being reduced to dismissive labels. Criticise their arguments, challenge their evidence, demand higher standards of proof, but do not diminish scholarship itself,” the letter said.
Concluding with a direct appeal to the standards of parliamentary democracy, the signatories stressed that public representatives wield profound influence over the tone of national conversations.
“In a democracy, disagreement is essential. Mockery is not a substitute for reasoned engagement. Public representatives wield enormous influence over the quality of national discourse. When complex scientific questions become objects of political ridicule, society loses an opportunity for informed debate. We hope future debates, especially within Parliament, will reflect these values. Our democracy deserves nothing less,” the letter emphasised.
Signatories include R.S. Dubey, Chancellor, National Institute of Educational Planning and Administration; V.K. Malhotra, Chairman, Madhya Pradesh State Food Commission; Sachin Chaturvedi, Vice-Chancellor, Nalanda University; Rajiv Kumar, former Vice-Chairman, Niti Aayog; Alok K. Rai, Director, IIM Calcutta and Rajat Moona, Director, IIT Gandhinagar, amongst others.
Published – July 30, 2026 10:00 pm IST
